NoLita · Pizza · Sicilian · New York Slice
NoLita's iconic Sicilian square slice shop — the Spicy Spring pepperoni cup turned a classic format into a social media phenomenon
Prince Street Pizza has been serving Sicilian square slices from its corner shop on Prince Street since 2012, and the Spicy Spring — thick-cut pepperoni cups curled and crisped on a square of fra diavolo-sauced dough with fresh mozz and pecorino — turned a classic format into a social media phenomenon. The square slice here has a proper bottom crust (crunchy from the oil in the pan) and an open, airy crumb, supporting toppings applied with conviction. The line snakes down the block on weekend afternoons. Prince Street Pizza is the argument that the New York slice format still has things to prove.
Prince Street Pizza is noLita's iconic Sicilian square slice shop — the Spicy Spring pepperoni cup turned a classic format into a social media phenomenon. Regulars order spicy spring (spicy pepperoni + fra diavolo) and mercer street margherita.
Prince Street Pizza is priced at $ — approx. under $20 per person.
Prince Street Pizza takes reservations by phone — call (212) 966-4100 to book.
Prince Street Pizza is at 27 Prince St, New York, NY 10012, in NoLita. Street spot in NoLita — walk up
Prince Street Pizza is open Mon–Thu 11:30 AM–9 PM · Fri–Sat 11 AM–10 PM · Sun 12–9 PM. Hours can change on holidays — confirm on Google Maps before a long drive.