Sheepshead Bay · Bakery
a local favorite whose bagels come out fluffier than most
Gerritsen Beach Bagels is a Bakery spot in Sheepshead Bay, and a local favorite whose bagels come out fluffier than most. Regulars point to the rainbow bagel and the pumpernickel everything bagel. Expect an inexpensive bill. It was picked from The Infatuation's Sheepshead Bay guide, so it is open and worth the trip.
Gerritsen Beach Bagels is a local favorite whose bagels come out fluffier than most. Regulars order rainbow bagel and pumpernickel everything bagel.
Gerritsen Beach Bagels is priced at $ — approx. under $20 per person.
Gerritsen Beach Bagels does not list an online reservation system. Walk-ins welcome; call ahead for larger parties
Gerritsen Beach Bagels is at 2712 Gerritsen Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11229, in Sheepshead Bay. Street parking; the subway is usually easier