a local favorite whose bagels come out fluffier than most
Must-try: Rainbow bagel, Pumpernickel everything bagel, Breakfast sandwich
📍 2712 Gerritsen Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11229
10 ranked dinner with friends restaurants in Sheepshead Bay, New York City — with ratings, must-try dishes and live availability.
10 picksThese are the 10 best Sheepshead Bay restaurants for a group dinner, ranked. Gerritsen Beach Bagels is the pick if you want the surest thing — 4.9 stars across 2,727 reviews. Most of this list stays under $40 a head. If you only order one thing, make it the rainbow bagel at Gerritsen Beach Bagels. None of these take online reservations — they are walk-in or phone-only, so go early.
Sheepshead Bay covers a lot of ground for its size — Bakery, American and Chinese are all well represented across the 10 spots we track here, and the neighborhood averages 4.4 stars.
a local favorite whose bagels come out fluffier than most
Must-try: Rainbow bagel, Pumpernickel everything bagel, Breakfast sandwich
📍 2712 Gerritsen Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11229
a decades-old counter whose motto is cheez on anything you pleez
Must-try: Roast beef sandwich, Corn nuggets, Cheese fries
📍 2901 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235
cutlets fried all day long, which is the whole foundation of the sandwich
Must-try: Chicken cutlet sandwich, Italian combo, Fresh daily cutlets
📍 1786 Sheepshead Bay Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11235
Uzbek portions generous enough that you should bring friends
Must-try: Pumpkin manti, Whole fish, Mixed grill kebab platter
📍 2818 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235
live tanks greet you, and the specials rotate with whatever is in them
Must-try: Ginger scallion lobster, Clams in black bean sauce, Peking-style pork chop
📍 1217 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11229
open since 1932 and still the benchmark for fried calamari and marinara
Must-try: Fried calamari, Baked clams, Zuppa di mussels
📍 2017 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235
open since 1938 and still provoking fierce loyalty among locals
Must-try: Roast beef sandwich, The Gargiulo, Corn nuggets
📍 3432 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11229
the destination for the best barbecued poultry in the neighborhood
Must-try: Cantonese barbecued meats, Singapore mei fun, Congee
📍 1410 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11229
a small Turkish cafe that dazzles well beyond its square footage
Must-try: Pistachio baklava rolls, Oreshki, Potato boregi
📍 2724 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11229
a Cantonese bakery where classic and bruleed egg tarts compete for your loyalty
Must-try: Egg tarts, Portuguese egg tarts, Milk tarts
📍 1310 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11229
Gerritsen Beach Bagels — 4.9 stars across 2,727 reviews, the highest on this list. a local favorite whose bagels come out fluffier than most.
None of the 10 on this page take online bookings — they are walk-in or phone-only. Going early, or on a weeknight, is the reliable move.
The rainbow bagel at Gerritsen Beach Bagels, the roast beef sandwich at Roll N Roaster and the chicken cutlet sandwich at Jimmy's Famous Heroes. Those are the dishes regulars point to first.
Ratings and review volume decide the order, but the list itself is drawn from restaurants people actually post about — 4 of the 10 here have a TikTok attached to their card. Every entry is checked as open before it ships.