Forks.NYCSheepshead BayBrennan & Carr

Sheepshead Bay  ·  American

Brennan & Carr

open since 1938 and still provoking fierce loyalty among locals

★★★★ 4.2  (3,761) $

About Brennan & Carr

Brennan & Carr is an American spot in Sheepshead Bay, and open since 1938 and still provoking fierce loyalty among locals. Regulars point to the roast beef sandwich and the the gargiulo. Expect an inexpensive bill. It was picked from The Infatuation's Sheepshead Bay guide, so it is open and worth the trip.

Must-try dishes

Roast beef sandwichThe GargiuloCorn nuggets
Address
3432 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11229
Hours
Hours vary — check Google Maps for today’s hours
Parking
Street parking; the subway is usually easier
Reservations
Walk-ins welcome; call ahead for larger parties

Perfect for

Casual DiningDinner with Friends

More restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

More american in NYC

Frequently asked questions

What is Brennan & Carr known for?

Brennan & Carr is open since 1938 and still provoking fierce loyalty among locals. Regulars order roast beef sandwich and the gargiulo.

How expensive is Brennan & Carr?

Brennan & Carr is priced at $ — approx. under $20 per person.

How do I make a reservation at Brennan & Carr?

Brennan & Carr does not list an online reservation system. Walk-ins welcome; call ahead for larger parties

Where is Brennan & Carr?

Brennan & Carr is at 3432 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11229, in Sheepshead Bay. Street parking; the subway is usually easier