✦ Bakery · Sheepshead Bay

Best Bakery Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

The best Bakery restaurants in Sheepshead Bay, New York City — 3 ranked picks with ratings and must-try dishes.

3 picks

Sheepshead Bay has 3 Bakery restaurants we would send anyone to, ranked here by rating and review depth. Gerritsen Beach Bagels sits at the top with 4.9 stars. If you only order one thing, make it the rainbow bagel at Gerritsen Beach Bagels. Most of this list stays under $40 a head. None of these take online reservations — they are walk-in or phone-only, so go early.

Sheepshead Bay is a Bakery-leaning pocket of New York City where the 3 restaurants we track average 4.3 stars.

Gerritsen Beach Bagels

Gerritsen Beach Bagels

Bakery  ·  Sheepshead Bay  ·  $

★★★★½ 4.9

a local favorite whose bagels come out fluffier than most

Must-try: Rainbow bagel, Pumpernickel everything bagel, Breakfast sandwich

📍 2712 Gerritsen Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11229

Full Details View on Maps
Safir Bakery & Cafe

Safir Bakery & Cafe

Bakery  ·  Sheepshead Bay  ·  $

★★★★☆ 4.0

a small Turkish cafe that dazzles well beyond its square footage

Must-try: Pistachio baklava rolls, Oreshki, Potato boregi

📍 2724 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11229

Full Details View on Maps
Long Wong Bakery II

Long Wong Bakery II

Bakery  ·  Sheepshead Bay  ·  $

★★★★☆ 4.0

a Cantonese bakery where classic and bruleed egg tarts compete for your loyalty

Must-try: Egg tarts, Portuguese egg tarts, Milk tarts

📍 1310 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11229

Full Details View on Maps

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best Bakery restaurant in Sheepshead Bay?

Gerritsen Beach Bagels — 4.9 stars across 2,727 reviews, the highest on this list. a local favorite whose bagels come out fluffier than most.

Do these restaurants take reservations?

None of the 3 on this page take online bookings — they are walk-in or phone-only. Going early, or on a weeknight, is the reliable move.

What should I order?

The rainbow bagel at Gerritsen Beach Bagels, the pistachio baklava rolls at Safir Bakery & Cafe and the egg tarts at Long Wong Bakery II. Those are the dishes regulars point to first.

More NYC Guides

📍 Restaurants Sheepshead Bay 🥂 Brunch Sheepshead Bay 🍻 Dinner with Friends Sheepshead Bay 🍔 Casual Dining Sheepshead Bay 🍽️ Bakery New York City