Forks.NYC›Great Kills›Anthony's Paninoteca

Great Kills  ·  Sandwiches

Anthony's Paninoteca

Sandwiches in Great Kills — 4.7 across 1,672 diner reviews

★★★★½ 4.7  (1,672) $
View on Google Maps Yelp reviews

About Anthony's Paninoteca

Watch Anthony's Paninoteca on TikTok

Anthony's Paninoteca is a Sandwiches spot in Great Kills, and a steady neighborhood draw — it carries a 4.7 rating across 1,672 diner reviews. Regulars point to the porchetta and the pastrami. It stays at the affordable end of the scale. It was picked from The Infatuation's Great Kills guide, so it is open and worth the trip.

Must-try dishes

PorchettaPastramiKiKi sandwich
Address
3994 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10308
Hours
Hours vary — check Google Maps for today’s hours
Parking
Street parking; subway is usually easier
Reservations
Walk-ins welcome; call ahead for larger parties
Directions
Open in Google Maps

Perfect for

Dinner with FriendsCasual Dining

Find it in these guides

Best Sandwiches in NYC

More sandwiches in NYC

Arrigo's Sandwiches · $$ · ★ 4.9 Faicco's Italian Specialities Sandwiches · $ · ★ 4.8 Royal Crown Sandwiches · $ · ★ 4.7 Jimmy's Famous Heroes Sandwiches · $ · ★ 4.6

Frequently asked questions

What is Anthony's Paninoteca known for?

Anthony's Paninoteca is sandwiches in Great Kills — 4.7 across 1,672 diner reviews. Regulars order porchetta and pastrami.

How expensive is Anthony's Paninoteca?

Anthony's Paninoteca is priced at $ — approx. under $20 per person.

How do I make a reservation at Anthony's Paninoteca?

Anthony's Paninoteca does not list an online reservation system. Walk-ins welcome; call ahead for larger parties

Where is Anthony's Paninoteca?

Anthony's Paninoteca is at 3994 Amboy Rd, Staten Island, NY 10308, in Great Kills. Street parking; subway is usually easier